Molrik Data

molrik.gif

TYPO3 sammenlignet med lignende systemer

CMS-systemer generelt har mange fællestræk, så hvordan beslutter man sig for hvilket system man skal vælge?

En afgørende faktor er ofte operativ-systemet på den server, hvor på siderne skal ligge. En anden er det benyttede programmeringssprog, som kan have betydning for blandt andet udbuddet af udvidelser til kerne-systemet. TYPO3 sammenlignes ofte med Joomla, Drupal og WordPress, som mere eller mindre deler systemkrav hvad angår platform, programmeringssprog og database.

Nedenfor ses en tabel, hvor en række parametre er sat op side om side for disse 4  CMS'er. Oplysningerne stammer fra sitet www.cmsmatrix.org, hvor man selv kan foretage sammenligninger med andre systemer.

 
Drupal 7.12
Joomla! 1.6.0
TYPO3 4.6
WordPress 3.0.4
 
System Requirements
 
 
Application Server
Apache
CGI
Apache
blank
 
Approximate Cost
Free
Free
Free
Free
 
Database
MySQL
MySQL
MySQL
MySQL
 
License
Open Source
Open Source
Open Source
Open Source
 
Operating System
Platform Independent
Platform Independent
Platform Independent
Platform Independent
 
Programming Language
PHP
PHP
PHP
PHP
 
Root Access
No
No
No
No
 
Shell Access
No
No
No
No
 
Web Server
Any
Any
Apache
blank
 
Security
 
 
Audit Trail
Yes
No
Yes
Limited
 
Captcha
Free Add On
Free Add On
Free Add On
No
 
Content Approval
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
 
Email Verification
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
 
Granular Privileges
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
 
Kerberos Authentication
No
No
Free Add On
No
 
LDAP Authentication
Free Add On
Yes
Free Add On
No
 
Login History
Yes
Yes
Yes
Free Add On
 
NIS Authentication
No
No
Free Add On
No
 
NTLM Authentication
Free Add On
No
Free Add On
No
 
Pluggable Authentication
Yes
Yes
Free Add On
Yes
 
Problem Notification
No
No
Yes
Free Add On
 
Sandbox
No
No
Yes
Limited
 
Session Management
Yes
Yes
Yes
Free Add On
 
SMB Authentication
No
No
Free Add On
No
 
SSL Compatible
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
 
SSL Logins
Free Add On
Yes
Yes
Yes
 
SSL Pages
Free Add On
Yes
Free Add On
Limited
 
Versioning
Yes
Free Add On
Yes
Free Add On
 
Support
 
 
Certification Program
Limited
No
Yes
No
 
Code Skeletons
Yes
Free Add On
Free Add On
No
 
Commercial Manuals
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
 
Commercial Support
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
 
Commercial Training
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
 
Developer Community
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
 
Online Help
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
 
Pluggable API
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
 
Professional Hosting
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
 
Professional Services
Yes
Yes
Yes
No
 
Public Forum
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
 
Public Mailing List
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
 
Test Framework
Yes
Yes
Free Add On
Yes
 
Third-Party Developers
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
 
Users Conference
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
 
Ease of Use
 
 
Drag-N-Drop Content
Free Add On
No
Free Add On
Yes
 
Email To Discussion
Free Add On
Free Add On
Free Add On
Limited
 
Friendly URLs
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
 
Image Resizing
Free Add On
Yes
Yes
Yes
 
Macro Language
Free Add On
Yes
Yes
Free Add On
 
Mass Upload
Free Add On
Yes
Yes
Yes
 
Prototyping
Limited
Yes
Free Add On
Free Add On
 
Server Page Language
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
 
Site Setup Wizard
Limited
No
Free Add On
No
 
Spell Checker
Free Add On
Free Add On
Yes
Yes
 
Style Wizard
Limited
No
Yes
No
 
Subscriptions
Free Add On
Yes
Free Add On
Free Add On
 
Template Language
Yes
Yes
Yes
No
 
UI Levels
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
 
Undo
Limited
No
Yes
Limited
 
WYSIWYG Editor
Free Add On
Yes
Yes
Yes
 
Zip Archives
No
No
Free Add On
Free Add On
 
Performance
 
 
Advanced Caching
Yes
Yes
Yes
Free Add On
 
Database Replication
Yes
No
Free Add On
Free Add On
 
Load Balancing
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
 
Page Caching
Yes
Yes
Yes
Free Add On
 
Static Content Export
No
No
Free Add On
Free Add On
 
Management
 
 
Advertising Management
Free Add On
Yes
Free Add On
No
 
Asset Management
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
 
Clipboard
No
No
Yes
No
 
Content Scheduling
Free Add On
Yes
Yes
Limited
 
Content Staging
Free Add On
No
Free Add On
No
 
Inline Administration
Yes
Yes
Yes
Free Add On
 
Online Administration
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
 
Package Deployment
Free Add On
No
Yes
No
 
Sub-sites / Roots
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
 
Themes / Skins
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
 
Trash
No
Yes
Yes
Yes
 
Web Statistics
Yes
Yes
Free Add On
Free Add On
 
Web-based Style/Template Management
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
 
Web-based Translation Management
Yes
Free Add On
Yes
Limited
 
Workflow Engine
Free Add On
No
Yes
No
 
Interoperability
 
 
Content Syndication (RSS)
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
 
FTP Support
Limited
Yes
Yes
Free Add On
 
iCal
Free Add On
Free Add On
Free Add On
No
 
UTF-8 Support
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
 
WAI Compliant
Limited
No
Free Add On
Limited
 
WebDAV Support
No
No
Free Add On
No
 
XHTML Compliant
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
 
Flexibility
 
 
CGI-mode Support
Yes
Yes
Yes
No
 
Content Reuse
Limited
Yes
Yes
No
 
Extensible User Profiles
Yes
Yes
Free Add On
Free Add On
 
Interface Localization
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
 
Metadata
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
 
Multi-lingual Content
Yes
Free Add On
Yes
Free Add On
 
Multi-lingual Content Integration
Yes
Free Add On
Yes
Free Add On
 
Multi-Site Deployment
Yes
Free Add On
Yes
No
 
URL Rewriting
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
 
Built-in Applications
 
 
Blog
Yes
Yes
Free Add On
Yes
 
Chat
Free Add On
Free Add On
Free Add On
Free Add On
 
Classifieds
Free Add On
Free Add On
Free Add On
Free Add On
 
Contact Management
Free Add On
Yes
Free Add On
Free Add On
 
Data Entry
Free Add On
Free Add On
Free Add On
Free Add On
 
Database Reports
Free Add On
Free Add On
Free Add On
No
 
Discussion / Forum
Yes
Free Add On
Free Add On
Free Add On
 
Document Management
Free Add On
Free Add On
Free Add On
No
 
Events Calendar
Free Add On
Free Add On
Free Add On
Free Add On
 
Events Management
Free Add On
Free Add On
Free Add On
Free Add On
 
Expense Reports
No
Free Add On
Free Add On
No
 
FAQ Management
Yes
Yes
Free Add On
Free Add On
 
File Distribution
Free Add On
Free Add On
Free Add On
Free Add On
 
Graphs and Charts
Free Add On
Free Add On
Free Add On
No
 
Groupware
Free Add On
Free Add On
Free Add On
No
 
Guest Book
Free Add On
Free Add On
Free Add On
Free Add On
 
Help Desk / Bug Reporting
Free Add On
Free Add On
Free Add On
No
 
HTTP Proxy
No
No
Free Add On
No
 
In/Out Board
Free Add On
No
No
No
 
Job Postings
Free Add On
Free Add On
Free Add On
Free Add On
 
Link Management
Free Add On
Yes
Free Add On
Yes
 
Mail Form
Free Add On
Yes
Yes
Free Add On
 
Matrix
No
No
Free Add On
No
 
My Page / Dashboard
Free Add On
No
Free Add On
Yes
 
Newsletter
Free Add On
Free Add On
Yes
Free Add On
 
Photo Gallery
Free Add On
Free Add On
Free Add On
Yes
 
Polls
Yes
Yes
Free Add On
Free Add On
 
Product Management
Free Add On
Yes
Free Add On
Free Add On
 
Project Tracking
Free Add On
Free Add On
Free Add On
No
 
Search Engine
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
 
Site Map
Free Add On
Free Add On
Yes
Free Add On
 
Stock Quotes
Free Add On
Free Add On
Free Add On
Free Add On
 
Surveys
Free Add On
Free Add On
Free Add On
Free Add On
 
Syndicated Content (RSS)
Yes
Yes
Free Add On
Yes
 
Tests / Quizzes
Free Add On
Free Add On
Free Add On
Free Add On
 
Time Tracking
Free Add On
Free Add On
Free Add On
Free Add On
 
User Contributions
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
 
Weather
Free Add On
Free Add On
Free Add On
Free Add On
 
Web Services Front End
Limited
Yes
Free Add On
Free Add On
 
Wiki
Free Add On
Free Add On
Free Add On
Free Add On
 
Commerce
 
 
Affiliate Tracking
Free Add On
Free Add On
Free Add On
No
 
Inventory Management
Free Add On
Free Add On
Free Add On
No
 
Pluggable Payments
Free Add On
Free Add On
Free Add On
No
 
Pluggable Shipping
Free Add On
Free Add On
Free Add On
No
 
Pluggable Tax
Free Add On
Free Add On
Free Add On
No
 
Point of Sale
Free Add On
Free Add On
No
No
 
Shopping Cart
Free Add On
Free Add On
Free Add On
No
 
Subscriptions
Free Add On
Free Add On
No
No
 
Wish Lists
Free Add On
Free Add On
Free Add On
No

Som det måtte fremgå af tabellen ovenfor, er der for TYPO3's vedkommende meget få funktioner, der ikke enten er indbygget i systemet eller nemt kan tilføjes med et plugin. Det er en af grundene til at jeg anbefaler TYPO3 frem for dets nærmeste konkurrenter.

Til toppen

bg